Evaluating progress is essential for accountability and making adjustments in DEIB efforts along the way. This involves monitoring activities and accomplishments, assessing the impact and merit, and using the information to improve the effort.
Key Questions to Consider
- What would success look like with DEIB, and how will we know it?
- What is the framework (logic model, or pathway) by which our activities will lead to improvement in desired outcomes for DEIB?
- How will we monitor what we are doing, and what we are achieving?
- How will we evaluate whether what we are doing is successful?
- How will we use the evaluation information for celebration, accountability, and improvement?
- How will we use an equity lens to see whether the effects of the effort benefit all people, especially groups that have had worse outcomes?
Some Recommended Actions
- Describe the program or initiative’s framework or logic model (i.e., pathway by which our DEIB activities will lead to intended outcomes). Include information about:
- Purpose or mission (i.e., the problem or goal to which the program, effort, or initiative is addressed).
- Context or conditions (i.e., the situation in which the effort will take place; factors that may affect outcomes)
- Inputs: Resources and barriers (i.e., Resources may include time, talent, equipment, information, money, etc.; Barriers may include history of inequities, inclusion, environmental factors, etc.)
- Activities or interventions (i.e., what the initiative will do to effect change and improvement) (e.g., provide information and enhancing skills; enhance services and support; modify access, barriers and opportunities; change the consequences; modify policies and broader systems)
- Outputs (i.e., direct evidence of having performed the activities) (e.g., targeted actions to those most affected; number of services provided)
- Intended effects or outcomes
- Short-term (e.g., organizational and systems changes)
- Intermediate (e.g., changes in behavior)
- Longer-term (e.g., improvement in outcomes; reduced inequities)
- Focus the evaluation questions and methods. Include:
- Evaluation questions – What information about the effort is important to stakeholders?
- Methods – What methods will be used to evaluate the effects of the program or initiative? (e.g., Monitoring and evaluation system; Behavioral surveys; Interviews with key participants; Archival records; Observations)
- Indicators of success – What indicators will be used to judge the success of the DEIB effort? Match the indicators to the evaluation questions.
- Outline and implement the evaluation plan. Indicate:
- How you will involve all stakeholders (i.e., including those most affected) in identifying indicators of success, documenting evidence of progress, and sense making about the overall initiative and how it can be improved.
- How you will track implementation of the intervention.
- How you will assess ongoing changes in specific objectives and outcomes (e.g., indicators; inequities).
- Make sense of the data and justify conclusions. This includes engaging stakeholders (including those most affected) in:
- Sensemaking and interpretation – How will we engage those responsible, and those most affected, in making sense of the data (i.e., what we are seeing, what it means)? How will we use the information to help answer the evaluation questions?
- Judgments – statements of worth or merit of the initiative. How will we communicate what the findings suggest about the value added by the effort?
- Recommendations – How will we identify recommendations based on the results of the evaluation?
- Use the information from the evaluation, including to:
- Celebrate accomplishments
- Make adjustments in activities and interventions
- Communicate lessons learned to stakeholders and relevant audiences
Evaluation Tools from the Community Tool Box
- Toolkit: Evaluating the Initiative
- Introduction to Evaluation
- Some Methods for Evaluating Comprehensive Community Initiatives
- Troubleshooting Guide: We don’t know how to evaluate our program or initiative
- Troubleshooting Guide: There is not enough improvement in outcomes
- Chapter 38, Section 6: Reaching Your Goals: The Goal Attainment Report